Black wealth still plummeting, CRL tells lawmakers
CHARLENE CROWELL | 9/14/2018, 12:41 p.m.
Center for Responsible Lending
For years, and particularly in recent months, major news outlets have heralded the nation’s robust economic recovery. From rising corporate profits, to lower unemployment, or rising stock prices on Wall Street, many consumers might conclude that financial stability not only returned after the Great Recession but continues to climb.
But for people of color, and specifically Black America, the state of the economy has not recovered. Instead of low unemployment, many who were laid off during the foreclosure crisis today are under-employed and cope with paychecks that lead to “more month than money.” Recent college graduates remain living with their parents, often due to burdensome student debt that delays them setting up their own households.
And for 4 in 10 adults last year, a single $400 unexpected expense led to borrowing, selling something or not being able to pay for it, according to a recent report by the Federal Reserve.
These seldom unacknowledged financial disparities emerged during testimony at a Capitol Hill hearing on Aug. 21. A subcommittee of the U.S. Senate’s Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions heard and learned about how a history of economic exclusion, combined with a more recent wealth shift to the top 10 percent of income earners, leads to a bleak financial future for people of color.
Scott Astrada, Federal Advocacy Director for the Center for Responsible Lending, testified to the “fear, anxiety and despair facing millions of Americans as they look toward a financial future plagued with uncertainty and loss.”
Citing data from multiple and recent research reports, Astrada noted a still-growing economic divide that has worsened since the Great Recession. Today, the wealthiest 10 percent now own 76 percent of the nation’s wealth, and the median net worth of Blacks and Latinos are respectively $11,000 and $14,000. Further, the May 2018 Federal Reserve’s Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2017 found that fewer than 40 percent of adults feel they are on track to retire with adequate savings, and 25 percent have no retirement savings at all.
“For households of color, the Great Recession erased the economic progress made over the past three decades in their entirety,” Astrada said. “If current trends continue, it will take 228 years for the average Black family to reach the level of wealth White families own today. For the average Latinx family, matching the wealth of White families will take 84 years.
“Ultimately, if current trends continue, Black household wealth is on the path to hit zero by 2053.”
Two long-standing federal policies were cited as key components to today’s financial disparities: government-backed mortgages and Social Security. Both federal programs, according to Astrada, have a sordid history of discrimination that brought long-lasting and significantly diminished and deliberate federal efforts to diminish the financial well-being of Black Americans.
In 1935, the year that Social Security began as a financial safety net for older Americans, the New Deal program excluded domestic and farm workers. Representing nearly a third of the nation’s workforce in the 1930s, these Americans were also largely people of color. A 2017 publication jointly released by Prosperity Now and the Institute for Policy Studies, The Road to Zero Wealth, tallied that long-time economic exclusion to be approximately $143 billion in 2016 dollars.